An at-fault accident can have long-term consequences on your car insurance. Insurance companies use your driving record to determine your premiums. If you are responsible for an accident, your rates may increase for several years. Understanding how long an at-fault accident stays on your insurance record is essential for managing your finances and making informed decisions.
This article explores how insurance companies handle at-fault accidents, how long they remain on your record, and how you can reduce their impact.
What Is an At-Fault Accident?
An at-fault accident is a traffic collision where you are found responsible for causing the crash. Insurance companies determine fault based on police reports, witness statements, and claim investigations.
Types of At-Fault Accidents
Minor Accidents – Small fender benders or low-impact crashes with little damage.
Major Accidents – Severe crashes that cause significant damage, injuries, or fatalities.
Regardless of the severity, an at-fault accident can affect your insurance rates.
How Do Insurance Companies Handle At-Fault Accidents?
Insurance companies assess risk when determining your premiums. A history of at-fault accidents indicates a higher likelihood of future claims, which results in higher rates.
Factors That Affect the Impact of an At-Fault Accident
Severity of the Accident – A minor accident may have a lower impact than a major one.
Claim Amount – Higher claims often lead to steeper rate increases.
State Laws – Some states have laws limiting how long an accident can affect your insurance.
Your Driving History – If you have multiple accidents, the impact may be greater.
Insurance Company Policies – Some insurers are stricter than others when evaluating accidents.
How Long Does an At-Fault Accident Stay on Your Insurance?
The duration that an at-fault accident affects your insurance varies by state and insurance provider. Generally, an accident stays on your insurance record for three to five years.
Typical Duration by Insurer
Most insurers: 3–5 years
Strict insurers: Up to 7 years for severe accidents
Lenient insurers: Some companies offer accident forgiveness programs
State-Specific Rules
Some states have specific laws that regulate how long an at-fault accident stays on your insurance. For example:
California – Accidents remain on your record for three years.
New York – At-fault accidents can affect insurance for up to five years.
Massachusetts – Insurance points last for six years.
Check with your state’s Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) for specific regulations.
How Much Will an At-Fault Accident Increase Insurance Rates?
Insurance rates typically rise after an at-fault accident, but the exact amount depends on several factors.
Average Premium Increases
Minor accident: 10%–20% increase
Moderate accident: 30%–50% increase
Severe accident: 50%–100% increase or more
According to industry data, an at-fault accident can increase premiums by $500 to $1,500 per year on average.
Other Factors That Influence the Rate Increase
Your Age – Younger drivers may face steeper penalties.
Your Insurance History – A long history with no accidents may reduce the impact.
Accident Forgiveness – Some insurers waive the first accident for long-term customers.
Can You Remove an At-Fault Accident from Your Insurance Record?
You cannot immediately remove an at-fault accident from your record, but you can take steps to minimize its impact.
Ways to Reduce the Effect of an At-Fault Accident
Drive Safely – Avoid further accidents to maintain a clean record.
Take a Defensive Driving Course – Some insurers offer discounts for completing safety courses.
Shop Around for Insurance – Compare rates from different providers to find better deals.
Ask About Accident Forgiveness – Some insurers will forgive one at-fault accident.
Wait for It to Expire – After three to five years, the accident will no longer affect your premiums.
Will an At-Fault Accident Affect Future Insurance Policies?
Yes, an at-fault accident may impact your ability to obtain a new insurance policy.
How It Affects New Policies
Higher Quotes – New insurers may charge more due to your accident history.
Policy Denials – Some companies may refuse to insure drivers with severe accidents.
Required SR-22 Insurance – In extreme cases, you may need special high-risk insurance.
If you need to switch providers, compare multiple insurers to find the best rate.
How to Lower Your Insurance Rates After an At-Fault Accident
Although an at-fault accident can increase your rates, there are ways to reduce your premiums.
Practical Steps to Save on Insurance
Increase Your Deductible – Higher deductibles can lower monthly premiums.
Bundle Insurance Policies – Combining auto and home insurance may provide discounts.
Maintain a Good Credit Score – Some insurers use credit scores to determine rates.
Look for Usage-Based Insurance – Some companies offer lower rates for safe drivers.
Request Discounts – Ask about discounts for good driving habits, multiple vehicles, or low mileage.
Does an At-Fault Accident Affect Other Types of Insurance?
An at-fault accident generally affects your car insurance, but it may also impact other policies.
Possible Effects on Other Insurance Policies
Life Insurance – Frequent accidents may indicate a higher risk level.
Health Insurance – Injuries from a car accident may increase future medical costs.
Home Insurance – Some insurers consider overall risk when determining rates.
Although the primary impact is on auto insurance, maintaining a safe driving record can benefit all aspects of insurance.
Conclusion
An at-fault accident can stay on your insurance for three to five years, depending on your state and insurance provider. During this time, you may experience higher premiums, but the impact can be minimized with safe driving and proactive measures.
To reduce costs, consider accident forgiveness programs, defensive driving courses, and shopping around for better rates. Over time, as the accident ages, its effect on your insurance will decrease. By maintaining a clean driving record, you can ensure lower premiums and better financial stability in the future.
Related topics:
