Mastercard Incorporated (NYSE: MA) faced a downgrade from Seaport analyst Jeff Cantwell, who lowered the stock’s rating from Buy to Neutral. The analyst set a price target of $521 for the stock, reflecting the view that Mastercard is currently fairly valued. While Cantwell maintains a positive outlook on Mastercard’s overall story, he does not see any immediate catalysts to drive further stock price growth in the short term.
Limited Revenue Upside in 2025
Cantwell notes that 2025 revenue upside for Mastercard may be limited due to its higher exposure to international markets, which poses more risks compared to Visa’s U.S.-centric revenue base. As a result, Mastercard could face greater challenges in a potential slowdown in personal consumption expenditures (PCE) growth abroad. The analyst’s shift in preference is also rooted in this divergence, as he now favors Visa over Mastercard due to Visa’s stronger position in the U.S. market where expectations are on the rise.
No Identifiable Catalysts for Growth
Another key reason for the downgrade is that Mastercard has already held its Investor Day, and Cantwell believes there are no clear upcoming catalysts that could spark significant growth for the company in the near future. This lack of identifiable growth drivers in 2025 has led the analyst to adopt a more cautious stance.
Economic Factors and Uncertainty
Cantwell also highlights broader economic factors that could impact Mastercard’s performance. With an upcoming administration change in the U.S., 2025 could bring increased policy uncertainty, affecting both consumer and business spending. Additionally, factors like foreign exchange rates (FX), inflation, and the Federal Reserve’s rate cuts further complicate the outlook for the stock. These external variables create a challenging environment for Mastercard to navigate in the coming year.
Fintech Sector and Investment Recommendations
Despite these challenges, Cantwell sees higher potential for earnings surprises in the Fintech sector this year compared to previous years, which may present opportunities for investors.
For those looking to gain exposure to Mastercard and the financial services sector, Cantwell suggests investing through Principal Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) like Principal Focused Blue Chip ETF (BATS: BCHP) and iShares U.S. Financial Services ETF (NYSE: IYG). These ETFs provide broader exposure to the financial sector, including Mastercard, while mitigating individual stock risk.
Related topics:
