Art insurance, as a unique form of property insurance, specifically covers the direct losses caused to artworks by fires, natural disasters, and other accidents. As the global art market continues to thrive and develop, art insurance has gradually garnered widespread attention from both industry insiders and the general public. This article will delve into the specifics of art insurance, exploring its types, pricing, importance, and market trends.
What is Art Insurance?
Art insurance is an economic safeguard specifically designed for the art industry. It establishes an insurance fund through mathematical predictions of uncertain events in the art industry and the collection of insurance premiums. In the form of a contract, it allows the majority to share the losses of a few, achieving risk transfer and financial planning goals for insurance buyers.
Art insurance can be categorized based on various factors. By the scope of the art industry, it can be divided into artwork insurance, music insurance, performance insurance, film and television insurance, and more. Based on the subject of insurance, it can be categorized into art personal insurance and art property insurance. Depending on the compensation and payment methods, it can be classified as compensatory art insurance and payment-based art insurance. Additionally, based on whether the premiums paid are returned, it can be divided into consumptive art insurance and refundable art insurance.
Types of Art Insurance
Comprehensive Art Insurance: This type of insurance provides broad coverage for various types of artworks, offering a comprehensive risk prevention network for collectors.
Specific Art Insurance: This insurance focuses on meeting the unique protection needs of specific artworks or high-value collections.
In China, art insurance products currently combine the attributes of traditional property insurance and transportation insurance. They primarily cover direct physical damage or loss to artworks caused by natural disasters or accidents during packaging, transportation, loading and unloading, handling, and while statically stored or exhibited. Coverage can also be extended to risks such as theft and earthquakes.
Artwork Insurance Coverage
Artwork insurance primarily covers artworks with historical, social, aesthetic, and collection value, or unique items that exceed their everyday functional value or the price of their raw materials. Examples include paintings, rare books and ancient manuscripts, photographic works, prints, etchings, embroidery, bronze ware, sculptures, pottery, porcelain, antique musical instruments, installation art, and more.
The main stakeholders related to the insured artworks can purchase insurance for them. Museums and art galleries can insure their collected or exhibited artworks. Auction houses, professional art storage companies, and galleries can insure artworks entrusted to them by collectors or artists for safekeeping or sale. Art logistics companies can insure artworks they are responsible for packaging and transporting. Enterprises or individuals can insure artworks they have purchased and collected.
The insurance value and coverage amount for artworks are determined based on various factors:
1. Original Purchase Cost
The actual purchase price of the artwork is used as the basis for determining the insurance value. Relevant value vouchers, such as invoices and receipts, must be provided when insuring. If the purchase was made a long time ago and the artwork has appreciated, the value can be increased according to market conditions. This pricing method is typically used for artworks collected by private individuals or businesses.
2. Agreed Value
Insurance is purchased based on the insurance value agreed upon by both parties. Domestic insurance companies usually require the insured/applicant to provide a value list of the artworks to be insured, which the insurance company will confirm. This method is commonly used by museums or large art galleries, especially public museums exhibiting artworks whose insured value is often much lower than their actual value. If the insurance company has objections to the insurance value provided by the client, both parties can negotiate to arrange for an authoritative third-party assessment, and ultimately insure based on the mutually agreed assessment value.
3. Limit Insurance
The value of each artwork is not specifically listed, only a total policy limit and a unit price limit for each subject. This method is generally used for projects with a very large number of items and frequent in-and-out movements, such as museum relocation projects for their collections.
4. Business Characteristics of the Applicant
For example, galleries and art dealers generally base insurance values on the cost of the artwork (excluding profit) or a specific percentage of the sales price (such as 60%) and certain additional fees. Auction houses typically determine insurance values and amounts based on the minimum reserve price (before auction) and the hammer price (after auction).
Pricing of Art Insurance
1. Pricing for art insurance is influenced by several factors:
Security Equipment and Management: Not only is it a risk factor that insurance companies assess when deciding whether to underwrite, but it is also crucial for determining insurance rates.
2. Risk Management During Art Transportation
This involves examining the qualifications and experience of the art packaging carrier. Choosing a carrier with professional experience in handling artworks can increase confidence in risk prevention. Additionally, the transportation mode and route are considered. Generally, risks increase sequentially from inland transportation within a city, domestic land transportation, international air transportation, to sea transportation, with corresponding increases in rates.
3. Value and Coverage Amount of Insured Artworks
The higher the total coverage amount, the larger the scale of premiums. Insurance companies can offer discounts based on the base rate when underwriting. For projects with lower coverage amounts, the average rate per policy tends to be higher. Meanwhile, the distribution of artwork values also affects rates. If risks are particularly concentrated on a few high-value items, rates may increase.
Market Trends and Development of Art Insurance
The global and Chinese art insurance markets have been growing steadily. According to art insurance market research reports, the sizes of the global and Chinese art insurance markets reached billions of yuan in 2023. The global art insurance market is projected to grow at a certain CAGR until 2029.
Development Stages of Art Insurance in China:
1. Initial Stage
In 1996, the People’s Insurance Company of China (PICC) first launched art insurance services, marking the official start of art insurance in China. This move provided risk protection for the art market and opened up new business areas for domestic financial institutions.
2. Gradual Development Stage
From 2004 to 2010, as market demand grew and the policy environment improved, art insurance gradually became more prevalent in major cities such as Beijing and Shanghai. Simultaneously, art insurance products and services began transitioning from reliance on imports to localized innovation.
3. Rapid Development Stage
In the latter half of the 21st century, the internationalization of the Chinese art market deepened further. Improvements in artwork value assessment, authentication technology, and laws and regulations provided a solid foundation for the development of art insurance. The size of the art insurance market expanded rapidly, and insurance companies increased their investments to secure a more favorable position in the market.
Importance of Art Insurance
Art insurance plays a vital role in art risk management. Artworks face multiple risks during storage, exhibition, and transportation, such as earthquakes, heavy rains, fires, theft, and more. According to surveys, transportation and handling losses account for 40% of art losses, theft for 38%, and fires, water damage, and soot damage for 18%. Art insurance provides economic compensation and risk management services to help art institutions and private collectors effectively mitigate these risks.
Art insurance is indispensable in art loss prevention management. It is not only a tool for economic compensation after artworks are damaged but also the most effective means and tool in art risk management. Art insurance safeguards the collections of art institutions and private collectors, bears risks, and collaborates with various professional resources to provide comprehensive services for the safety of collections, such as digitalization of collections, training in loss prevention skills, and guidance on daily storage.
Furthermore, art insurance contributes to the standardized and healthy development of the art industry. Insurance institutions, as liaisons in various sectors of the art industry, unite with professional institutions in various fields to develop industry standards, grant qualifications to relevant institutions, and ensure the long-term standardized and healthy development of the art industry.
Conclusion
Art insurance is an indispensable part of the art industry, playing a significant role in art risk management, loss prevention, and industry standardization. As the Chinese art market continues to rise globally, art insurance will attract more international capital attention. Meanwhile, strengthening cooperation with other countries and regions to build an international art risk management system, including cross-border protection services and risk management and support during cross-regional art circulation, will further enhance the robustness of art insurance.
Insurance companies and investors must make timely and effective market decisions to succeed in the fierce market competition. Understanding the unsatisfied market needs and trends within the industry can help avoid investment risks and more efficiently consolidate or expand corresponding strategic target markets, firmly grasping the initiative in industry competition.
In summary, art insurance, with its unique features and comprehensive coverage, is a crucial financial tool for the art industry. It not only provides economic safeguards but also promotes the standardized and healthy development of the entire art market. As the art market continues to evolve, art insurance will undoubtedly play an increasingly important role, safeguarding the cultural heritage and creativity of human civilization.
Related topics：
